I, in common with most other taxpayers, resent being called a customer of HM Revenue & Customs, when there really is no choice of supplier. We are captives of the system and we cannot take our business elsewhere. This is an old saw, but if we are customers, we have to ask what we are getting in terms of service; value for what we pay is another matter, and one of a political nature.
HMRC, or at least the Inland Revenue as they were called, did once upon a time provide a service to individual taxpayers, prior to Self Assessment. Of course many people feared the tax man as they thought, even though going back a long time the majority of staff were women as now. However, with minor errors in Tax Returns or even quite major but obviously unintentional incorrect completion of Returns, one could expect a letter suggesting a correct interpretation, or very often a telephone call from the Tax Office along the lines of “Have you forgotten your bank interest? Drop us a line with the figures and we will make an adjustment.”
Now it is true to say that there was a lot wrong with the old system. There was a tradition of issuing estimated assessments every year against which the taxpayer or the adviser would appeal as a matter of routine, but this was largely a question of regulating the flow of tax payments as routinely one would offer a payment on account. It was a daft system latterly (that is prior to 1996-97) but it was a system that was many years out of date. The estimated assessment routine became more fashionable in the latter stages before Self Assessment as the Revenue realised that they had to get money in. When I started in tax, one rarely saw an assessment issued unless a Tax Return had been put in, and there was little incentive for the more laissez faire taxpayers to do so. Why put in a tax return and have to pay tax, cutting into one's holiday money for St. Trop?
So, something had to be done, and though there had been tightening up of interest charges for late payment of tax, there really needed to be a system of making people submit tax returns and fining them if they didn't, as other jurisdictions already did. I think the Revenue had looked at America's Internal Revenue Service and thought they were along the right lines.
Anyway, the major change was to make people responsible for calculating their own tax liabilities, and with the wholesale introduction of a new computer system they had an automatic checking facility and automated fines and levies of interest charges. The major triumph at the time was to start massive cost cutting (this is one thing we cannot blame the current Government for) by getting rid of more qualified staff who actually knew about tax in favour of computers and call centre staff. Not all of this happened at the same time; there has been and will continue to be for a while yet an ongoing process of closing tax offices in favour of call centres and reducing the numbers of personnel who actually understand tax issues.
As the onus is now on the “customer” to calculate his or her tax due, this means that many who originally filled in the figures and waited for an assessment now have to either employ someone to prepare the accounts and tax return or wade into the online service and hope the figures they put in are the correct ones, especially if they are based on prepared accounts.
I earn my living to quite an extent by preparing Tax Returns and accounts for people who are not confident or know they are not competent to do it themselves. Obviously I am not complaining about this, but I think it is unfortunate that the amateur has to wade through so much information to manage without help. The Tax Return Guide is helpful with the basics, but cannot educate anyone in all the tax rules that we professionals have to know, and that is fundamentally unfair. It means that the individual taxpayers largely have to pay someone else to do what the Civil Service used to do on their behalf.
It is not as though information is very easy to find on the HMRC website. Although at a tax professionals' meeting with HMRC we were told that the website was being made much easier to use, I had to use Google to find on the HMRC website what their own search facility could not: that 5.75 million tax returns were filed online for 2008-09 by the deadline of 31st January 2009. I suspect a good proportion of those filed were by agents such as my firm. There were many glitches using HMRC's own online program, such as an inability to bring forward trading or lettings losses from a previous year. There was a work-around involving writing a note to oneself for next year. I did one Return using HMRC's own software, and had I not been a professional I would have been driven to distraction and probably given up.
The point of writing this piece is not to say that we should go back to the bad old days of estimated assessments, and the confusing-for-many previous year basis of taxing trading and untaxed sources. It is just that over ten years down the line of Self Assessment there is still so much work to be done in terms of improving the system and getting an HMRC website that is fit for purpose. Yes, the information is mostly there and the site is vast, but if a tax and internet geek like me cannot whistle up the content I need in short order, what hope is there for someone who has little tax knowledge, because that person will not even know what he or she is looking for? HMRC need to look at the news websites such as the BBC and CNN to see how the categories can be drilled down better into general headings, with menus underneath, sub menus and so on, so that amateurs (and journalists trying to check the ins and outs of MPs' expenses or whatever) can find what they are looking for.
Why has it taken so long to make the system work, and how much longer is it going to take? When is the “customer” going to benefit from doing all the work on the Government's behalf? Is not the taxpayer in reality more of a part-time contractor or employee engaged by the Treasury?
Have you submitted your Tax Return yet?
On our bikes
Exemplary Consulting for Business Support
Follow me on Twitter